【Western Archives】
The Western Archivestech industry has put San Francisco at the heart one of the biggest waves of wealth creation in history.
But a huge number of the city's residents have seen little of its spoils.
SEE ALSO: How people reacted when a 'homeless' child knocked on their door on HalloweenFor them, the skyrocketing cost of living has turned everyday life in their hometown into a starkly different reality from that of its wealthier inhabitants.
That experience gap served as the inspiration for a new ad campaign from low-income relief group Tipping Point, which seeks to put viewers in the shoes of San Franciscans living below the poverty line.
To do so, the nonprofit arranged a Twilight Zone-esque experience for some unwitting shoppers in a small downtown market.
The organizers decked out the entire store with marketing material for a seeming sales promotion called "Poverty Line Prices." But instead of seeing a discount when they reached the checkout counter, customers were confronted with prices five times more than what they'd normally pay.
A hidden camera captured their bemused and irritated reactions as a straight-faced cashier acted as if nothing was out of the ordinary.
The two-minute online video is paired with an interactive tool where visitors can get a sense of how much more expensive rent and other various living expenses would feel were their own income below the poverty line.
The stunt was the brainchild of San Francisco ad agency Goodby, Silverstein & Partners, which partnered with Tipping Point on a pro bono basis for the campaign.
Rich Silverstein, a partner and co-chairman at the agency, said the goal was to bring about empathy for low-income residents without making their plight seem pitiful or shaming viewers into feeling bad.
He said the agency tried hard to avoid some of the clichés that sometimes infect charity advertising of this kind.
"In many ways, it's 'A Tale of Two Cities.'"
"It was very important that it came across with the utmost respect for the integrity of the people of the Bay Area. We didn't want to denigrate anyone who lives here," Silverstein said. "There are traps you can fall into, and we tried to avoid those."
Eventually, the agency's creative team realized that the disconcerting disparity in the numbers was enough to tell a meaningful and straightforward story on its own.
San Francisco boasts a median household income of around $150,000 -- well above of the national average -- yet Tipping Point says one in ten households still subsist on incomes below the $24,300 poverty line.
"In many ways, it's 'A Tale of Two Cities,'" Silverstein says, citing the famous opening lines of the Charles Dickens classic as an apt description of contemporary life in San Francisco.


Tipping Point has been around for more than a decade, but the campaign marks its biggest advertising effort to date.
"We're well known among a few different groups in the Bay Area and the country but not as well-known as we'd like," says Tipping Point CEO and founder Daniel Lurie. "We just wanted to make something that made people stop and think."
The group is unique in that it's able to put 100 percent of its donations towards those in need, thanks to a board of directors that covers all operating costs.
Since its inception in 2005, the nonprofit has raised more than $120 million, and last year alone, it helped 22,000 people move toward a path out of poverty.
Lurie said now seemed to be the perfect time for the group's message, as the chaos of election season dies down and the holiday season approaches.
The campaign is running in only in print ads and online placements for now but may expand depending on donated media space.
BONUS:
Search
Categories
Latest Posts
Brest vs. PSG 2025 livestream: Watch Champions League for free
2025-06-27 02:12NYT Strands hints, answers for November 16
2025-06-27 01:55Black Friday 2024 SSD deals: Best picks for PS5, Xbox, and more
2025-06-27 00:47Best Buy Black Friday TV deal: Save $250 on Hisense QD6 QLED 4K TV
2025-06-27 00:35Popular Posts
Optogenetics: A Virtual Reality System for Controlling Living Cells
2025-06-27 02:18Early Black Friday TV deals at Walmart include a $138 50
2025-06-27 02:12Who's who in 'Dune: Prophecy': Every character you need to know
2025-06-27 00:52Best GPU deal: Get the MSI RTX 5080 for $1,249.99 at Best Buy
2025-06-27 00:44Featured Posts
The Onion buys Infowars. What it will do with it.
2025-06-27 01:32Black Friday 2024 SSD deals: Best picks for PS5, Xbox, and more
2025-06-27 01:15Swole Jeff Bezos joins Instagram to tease his new ROCKET FACTORY
2025-06-27 00:39Popular Articles
Meta says some AGI systems are too risky to release
2025-06-27 02:22Wordle today: The answer and hints for November 15
2025-06-27 01:04The Portable Workstation: Dell XPS 13 + 32 UltraSharp 4K Monitor
2025-06-26 23:57Newsletter
Subscribe to our newsletter for the latest updates.
Comments (21744)
Flying Information Network
Lego free Valentine's Day Heart: How to get free Lego
2025-06-27 02:07New Knowledge Information Network
NYT Connections hints and answers for November 17: Tips to solve 'Connections' #525.
2025-06-27 01:36Original Force Information Network
Black Friday Best Buy Doorbuster deal: Get the LG OLED B4 48
2025-06-27 01:28Information Information Network
Paraguay vs. Argentina 2024 livestream: Watch World Cup Qualifiers for free
2025-06-27 00:50Unconstrained Information Network
Lego free Valentine's Day Heart: How to get free Lego
2025-06-27 00:17